Registered charity no. 283936

bios

BIOS REPORTER

July 2003, Vol.XXVI, No.3

MEETINGS REPORTS


1. BIOS DAY CONFERENCE - THE 18.46 FROM PADDINGTON


27 APRIL 2002
ALL SAINTS', HASLINGFIELD
PAUL JOSLIN

The massive gothic tower of All Saints', Haslingfield dominates the countryside around Cambridge; the church itself provided the venue for a stimulating and informative day of organ history.
   It began with a short voluntary by Thomas Adams, played by Peter Bumstead. José Hopkins then outlined the story of the organ, which has been recently installed in the church, and its journey from Paddington to the Fens. It had been built in 1846 for Holy Trinity, Bishops Bridge Road, Paddington, which was a large neo-gothic design by Thomas Cundy, seating over 1,000; the organ, a relatively modest instrument costing £422 was superseded by a much larger organ by Lewis. In 1882 J.C. Bishop had re-erected the instrument, with small additions, in Ely Parish Church for £207, but without a case; the manual and pedal compasses were altered to contemporary specifications. With only few minor changes, the pipework and most of the structure of the organ survived in original condition. A restoration, slightly unsympathetic, was carried out in 1977; the instrument fell out of use in the 1990s, when St Mary's acquired and electronic instrument.
   Haslingfield needed such an organ and, after seven years of detailed planning and negotiation, the fine organ now in the north aisle was installed. Peter Bumstead, the organ-builder, spoke of his extensive work in restoring this large two-manual instrument, carefully preserving the original work while producing an instrument useful for present-day requirements.

Hasl

The Great and Swell have been largely restored to the original specification and are controlled by the Bishop console; the new castellated case fits well, and incorporates ten of the original display pipes hitherto concealed in the organ. During the restoration of the Swell soundboard an inscription on the parchment at the back of the pallets was discovered. This records 'The first soundboard made without the aid of a foreman by C.J. Coleman 1845'. Underneath are the signatures of several 'witnesses' including 'James Bishop. Boss' and 'E. Willis' (a brother of Henry Willis). Alongside the word 'Boss' someone who clearly did not fear for his livelihood has written 'alias dummy'.
   Gillian Ward Russell gave a talk entitled Early nineteenth-century organ repertoire - reflecting the awareness of J.S. Bach. In a comprehensive lecture, she declared that early nineteenth-century musicians and composers were strongly influenced by the music of Handel, Haydn and Mozart; the availability and knowledge of the music of J.S. Bach were limited. English organ voluntaries of the period invariably followed the pattern of a slow introduction followed by a fugue, a type illustrated in an example by William Russell. It was largely left to Samuel Wesley, who studied early editions of the '48' and was 'besotted' with the music of J.S. Bach (he named his son 'Sebastian' in 1810), to write a set of fortepiano preludes in 1797 in the style of Bach. It was surprising to learn that Wesley's organ music had sparing pedal parts.
   There was a brief discussion of S.S. Wesley's music. Although taught by his father, and a great player of Bach fugues, he rarely imitated Bach, disdained equal temperament, and used bold, individual harmonies influenced by Louis Spohr. Dr Ward Russell concluded with a performance of the first movement of Bach's Trio Sonata in E flat, BWV525, played as a duet with the assistance of Hilary Norris, who, after lunch, gave a lecture entitled Rococo to Romanticism - English organ repertoire 1800-1850. She covered many aspects of the organ literature of the period, including interpretation (the invention of the metronome in 1815, registration, use of the swell-pedal, phrasing, articulation, ornaments, cadenzas) and vocal and instrumental influences (Vincent Novello, Italian opera, virtuoso singing, oratorio, cantatas, glees and catches, English song).
   English audiences continued to be influenced by the works of Handel, particularly The Messiah. Fugues were often played at recitals but they were normally preceded by an improvised prelude. Hilary drew attention to important composers and their music, including the late 1744-48 concertos by Stanley and the c.1815 concertos by Matthew Camidge. After numerous examples, she completed her excellent lecture with the Voluntary in C by Samuel Webbe (the younger, c.1770-1843) which demonstrated bizarre figuration and a written cadenza.
   Peter Bumstead concluded the day with a lecture, The musical world of J.C. Bishop, in which he discussed the re-evaluation of Bishop's work 1783-1854 in the light of the work at Haslingfield and Bermondsey. He briefly chronicled the landmarks in the firm's history and the varying names adopted by the business. Organs were built with either the old GG or the new C compass throughout the 1840s and 1850s. As part of a discussion on the Hereford Cathedral organ in 1832, Peter sang the baritone solo from The Wilderness, accompanied by Peter Butcher; Wesley, who was the organist in 1832 , wrote the anthem for the opening of the organ.
   History has not been kind to J.C. Bishop.
Bish

From enjoying a position of prominence, he has fallen into relative obscurity and few of his instruments remain. Not given to experiment, and producing organs that were lightly-blown and sweet-sounding, he nevertheless invented the Clarabella and composition pedals; his influence on later nineteenth-century builders was considerable.
   A pleasing feature of the day was the illustration of the lectures by copious musical examples, making this an informative and instructive day. Thanks are due to José Hopkins and her team of helpers for arranging this successful conference.

2. HOCS ASSESSORS TRAINING DAY
10 and 11 MAY 2002
MIDLAND ORGAN WORKS
JOHN HUGHES

The new criteria adopted by Council for the Historic Organs Certificate Scheme led to this training meeting at the Midland Organ Works, Melton Mowbray, courtesy of Christopher Gray, BIOS Conservation Officer. A dozen invited assessors attended to be instructed in and discuss the application of the criteria in the field; the primary purpose was to ensure a consistency in the approach and method adopted by assessors and in their reports to the HOCS committee.
   Christopher Gray gave a detailed exposition of the physical aspects of organ-building so that assessors could not only record details of construction, actions and winding accurately and uniformly, but assess alterations. David Knight discussed the various types of bellows and winding systems to be found in British organs.There was a great deal of lively discussion of the details, illumination of some points being achieved by examples in the workshop. Dominic Gwynn discussed the problems and pitfalls of assessing the age and authenticity of pipework, producing some eighteenth-century examples for examination.
   There followed field visits to assess two organs against the HOCS criteria. The first was a Joseph Walker of 1874 in near original condition, restored recently by Peter Collins; this fascinating instrument produced some fiery discussion among the assessors.
   The other instrument inspected had a sumptuous art nouveau case. This raised the question of granting the organ a status under the HOCS scheme solely on the grounds of its unusual appearance, rather than any musical or historical grounds.

Return to Index Page for this issue

Return to Reporter Index Page